Wednesday, March 29, 2006

Habeas Corpus: Today and Yesterday

Here's a taste of the fireworks in the Supreme Court today in the Hamdan case, as told by NY Times:


Mr. Clement's position was that Congress had not in fact suspended habeas corpus, but that it might constitutionally have done so given "the exigencies of 9/11." Addressing Justice Stevens, the solicitor general said, "My view would be that if Congress sort of stumbles upon a suspension of the writ, that the preconditions are satisfied, that would still be constitutionally valid."

Justice Souter interrupted. "Isn't there a pretty good argument that suspension of the writ of habeas corpus is just about the most stupendously significant act that the Congress of the United States can take," he asked, "and therefore we ought to be at least a little slow to accept your argument that it can be done from pure inadvertence?"

When Mr. Clement began to answer, Justice Souter persisted: "You are leaving us with the position of the United States that the Congress may validly suspend it inadvertently. Is that really your position?"

The solicitor general replied, "I think at least if you're talking about the extension of the writ to enemy combatants held outside the territory of the United States —— "

"Now wait a minute!" Justice Souter interrupted, waving a finger. "The writ is the writ. There are not two writs of habeas corpus, for some cases and for other cases. The rights that may be asserted, the rights that may be vindicated, will vary with the circumstances, but jurisdiction over habeas corpus is jurisdiction over habeas corpus."

Hat tip The Moderate Voice


A group of British MPs filed an amicus brief to the Supreme Court recently, offering their perspective on the legal status of the Guantanamo prisoners. For a bit of historical perspective, I highly recommend this transcript of NPR's This American Life (the middle segment). The piece nicely paints a picture of the moment when habeas corpus was last suspended in England.

1 Comments:

At 1:20 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Weight loss has become a well furnished business for many scrupulous people. Nowadays people have become very much beauty and skin conscious and as a result they are going for weight loss in huge numbers. Weight loss has become the main ingredient of beauty, smartness, and health. Thus looking into this growing demand for weight loss, there are many who take advantage and make it a business. There are fake organizations either provide fake medicines or fake trainers, and charge exorbitant amounts from the clients. So while going for weight loss it is very important to check the authenticity of the organization or the drugs.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home